Ending Week 3
- Justin Hui
- Apr 18, 2021
- 2 min read
We started off the week by reading the chapter "Whines and Pet Peeves" by Safina. In this chapter he goes into results found by other scientists and especially into the concepts such as "Theory of Mind" and tests like the Mirror test.
Personally, I really enjoyed reading the chapters and reading about Safina's critics on these tests. What I found very interesting is how Safina clearly disagreed with many of the conclusions made by these scientists who conducted the tests. Really, after reading the chapter it really made me understand the flaws of many of these "intelligence" tests and that being able to say an animal is intelligent is as simple as solving a single puzzle or a test.
Overall, from these first weeks I think one of the topics I'm most curious about is social structures and friendship in animals. There are a lot of examples but I was interested from the Time Magazine article. Additionally, birds and bird intelligence seems fairly interesting because of the fact it they are non-mammals. Many of the famously intelligent animals, such as dolphins, apes, and elephants are all mammals; so the fact many birds show a lot of intelligence is very interesting and may have connotations to other intelligence species outside of the umbrella of mammals.

So far, most of my research has not really come up with anything particular stand-out. I think I am still a little unsure of what I want to write about later on, so nothing for me to really look for. The research done by John Marzluff on crows was very interesting. There was also a lot more from information from Bird Brains that seemed useful. Really, I plan on continuing to look around for sources to see how I feel about this topic, but things are still very tentative.




Hi, Justin! It is interesting to say that an animal is intelligent due to solving puzzles. I also can understand your confusion about the topic of the essay. Hope you can decide your topic soon.
Interesting point of view. I see your dilemma, if you are seeing conflicting points of view it's going to be harder to find a specific direction that you want to write about. Good luck, hopefully the other research helps in you in forming your topic.
h
Hey Justin! I like how you mentioned that many intelligence tests are flawed because I never thought about how most animals that were claimed smart are because of them solving a single puzzle. If you think that intelligence tests are inaccurate, what do you think will be the best way to measure an animal's intelligence? You can try going on Google Scholar or Twitter and look up your different areas of interest to help you narrow down on which species to research about.
Hey Justin! I read that chapter as well. It's definitely a point of interest when Safina critiques the experiments of some previous researchers. After reading the chapter, I can say that Safina's perspective makes a lot of sense. Intelligence isn't so simple that you could determine it with a simple puzzle. And besides, animals are intelligent in a lot of ways that humans aren't.
I'm interested by what you're going to find in terms of aviary intelligence. It looks like you're still working on that, so I'm looking forward to some cool bird stuff.